What Occurs to an EV in a Automotive Crash!

Help CleanTechnica’s work by way of a Substack subscription or on Stripe.

On the eighth January this 12 months, Ron Male was concerned in a spectacular automotive crash. A four-car pileup no much less. His BYD Seal was the primary in line, adopted by three petrol vehicles — a Nice Wall, a Mazda, and a BMW. Seems to be just like the Mazda was the crumple zone! Ron tells me that the drivers gathered ’spherical and talked about their expertise. He instructed them that his automobile was a BEV. Nobody within the group appeared notably bothered.

Two fireplace engines attended. Opposite to expectations, his BYD Seal AWD Efficiency didn’t burst into flames. However there was fairly a dialog about the right way to isolate the battery. When the primary responders reported that that they had achieved that, Ron identified that the display was nonetheless clearly ON. “Let me flip my automotive OFF,” he remonstrated. He tells me that “I merely turned it off, then popped the bonnet to isolate the 84 kW battery.”

“I obtained a name from the repairer asking me how my rear seat was destroyed. The hearth brigade had really PEELED the seat lining off the body INSTEAD of lifting the rear seat as much as entry the battery. I DO truthfully imagine the hearth brigade require FURTHER coaching on ALL EVs.” My ideas are that there might be an unlimited enchancment in the event that they obtained coaching in simply BYD and Tesla, as they’re the most typical EVs on Australian roads.

It seems from the photographs Ron provided that as he was slowing down, a Nice Wall Haval slowed right down to match his pace, however the different two vehicles, a Mazda and a BMW, clearly didn’t. The BMW ran up the rear of the Mazda because it rammed into the again of the Haval. Ron’s BYD Seal was the one automotive not written off.

The insurance coverage firm has spent three weeks totally checking all of the wiring earlier than sending the automotive off for repairs. Ron has nothing however reward for Suncorp Insurance coverage. Although, the ICE loaner automotive has been driving him loopy. “I may by no means return to an ICE automobile once more!” He shared the prices with us: “I’ve all the time insured my vehicles, together with Holden Particular Autos, Mercedes AMGs, and now BYD with Suncorp. They’ve been actually wonderful telling me what’s occurring. Insurance coverage prices AU$1,350 per 12 months with a $700 extra. However I wasn’t at fault. So didn’t pay a cent, naturally.”

The hearth brigade attends automotive accidents attributable to the opportunity of a hearth from flamable supplies leaking from broken engines (oil) and petrol tanks. It provokes the thought — what kind of powertrain is essentially the most harmful when a automotive is broken? Petrol diesel, hybrid, or battery electrical?

Based on the Electrical Automobile Hub, each electrical automobile examined within the final 5 years has obtained a 5-star ANCAP (Australian New Automotive Evaluation Program) security score. ANCAP is “the gold commonplace of automotive security testing.” In reality, EVs are sometimes safer than inner combustion engine vehicles. For instance, they maintain “the highest three positions within the Nationwide Freeway Visitors Security Administration (NHTSA) rollover security testing. The Tesla Mannequin S got here first, adopted by the Tesla Mannequin X and Chevrolet Volt joint second.”

With a decrease centre of gravity, they’ve higher, safer dealing with. No gearbox or engine will intrude into the cabin to break the occupants. The liquid gas in an ICE automotive is just coated in a number of millimetres of plastic. An EV’s battery is surrounded by centimetres of steel.

EVs don’t explode in an accident, that’s what petrol vehicles do. “AutoInsuranceEZ* (US) checked out American-only information from the Nationwide Transport Security Board, the Bureau of Transport Statistics & Automobile Remembers from 2020 to conclude: ‘Hybrid autos really are available in primary with essentially the most fires per 100K gross sales. Gasoline autos are second, and electrical autos place third, with solely 25 fires per 100K electrical automobile gross sales. Based mostly on this information, electrical autos don’t catch fireplace practically as a lot because the information claims. Hybrid vehicles appear to be essentially the most harmful for fires, adopted by fuel autos,’” EVfiresafe writes.

Ron shared his story at our current espresso, cake, and EVs morning and provoked fairly a dialogue concerning the want for electrical autos to have an simply identifiable high-voltage battery isolator change. And for first responders to be educated in finding and actioning such a change.

Ron has obtained phrase that he ought to get his BYD Seal AWD Efficiency again by the 18th March. It should have been within the store for two months and 10 days. He’ll be assembly me for espresso once more subsequent week and we’ll see how he’s coping along with his ICE loaner. His future must be shiny and electrical.