Nigeria is the one different nation that treats Bitcoin as a safety. Why?

Sixteen years after it launched as a libertarian experiment to sidestep authorities management, Bitcoin nonetheless defies straightforward classification. Is it cash, a speculative asset, or just digital gold? For regulators, notably in rising markets like Nigeria, that query is way from tutorial.

In September 2020, Nigeria’s Securities and Alternate Fee (SEC) categorised Bitcoin and different cryptocurrencies as securities, a call cemented within the nation’s 2025 Funding and Securities Act.

The transfer locations Bitcoin beneath capital markets oversight, mirroring coverage suggestions from the Worldwide Organisation of Securities Commissions (IOSCO), which says crypto-asset merchandise ought to comply with the identical investor-protection guidelines as conventional monetary devices when their financial features are related.

Nevertheless, the character and utility of Bitcoin make it a tough asset to categorise. Let’s argue the circumstances.

The case for securities

A safety is a illustration of cash. Like bearer bonds or shares, it provides the holder monetary rights and sometimes entails the expectation of revenue, typically primarily based on the work of others. When Firm A points securities, traders who purchase into what it’s promoting can revenue from their funding if the corporate performs effectively.

If Bitcoin is regulated as a safety, it could deliver nearer oversight to the crypto business. Exchanges, token issuers, and intermediaries should submit audited experiences, comply with strict disclosure guidelines, and adjust to anti-fraud laws. These guidelines, drawn from conventional capital markets, shield traders and guarantee truthful play.

It is a dicey scenario. First, in accordance with the Howey Take a look at, a transaction qualifies as a safety if it entails an funding of cash in a typical enterprise with the expectation of revenue, primarily from the efforts of others. It’s a authorized check utilized in the USA to find out what falls beneath securities legislation.

Bitcoin arguably fails the check. There’s no identifiable promoter, no central enterprise managing it, and no coordinated effort driving its worth. Individuals could put money into Bitcoin hoping for revenue, however the worth is moved by market dynamics, not the actions of a single issuer or staff. 

That’s why regulators in lots of nations, together with the US Commodity Futures Buying and selling Fee (CFTC), have leaned towards calling it a commodity. However, Nigeria’s SEC thinks in another way about this.

“The [Nigerian] SEC’s mandate is to guard authorities pursuits and residents, and it’s executing it appropriately right here,” stated Tami Koroye, a digital asset regulation lecturer on the College of Bradford. “Whereas Bitcoin and different early cryptocurrencies had been designed as libertarian fee programs free from conventional banking, that’s merely not how Nigerians are utilizing them at present.”

Nigeria is certainly one of simply two nations—alongside Malaysia—that explicitly deal with Bitcoin as a safety.

Whereas Bitcoin was designed to be cash, it isn’t in most areas. Traditionally, solely two nations, El Salvador and the Central African Republic (CAR), have made Bitcoin authorized tender in 2021 and 2022, respectively. 

That rapidly turned out to be a nasty concept. As a consequence of its volatility, many merchants refused to simply accept the digital asset as a way of fee. It additionally undermined central banks’ skill to subject financial coverage selections successfully as a result of Bitcoin is decentralised and can’t be managed. 

The Worldwide Financial Fund (IMF) has suggested each nations to overturn this rule. Whereas El Salvador nonetheless retains reserves in Bitcoin, each nations have reversed their selections to make the asset authorized tender.

As cash, Bitcoin fails two of the three financial assessments. It fails woefully as a unit of account, however it works effectively as an funding device (retailer of worth). However its utility as a medium of alternate is nuanced. Whereas Bitcoin is not authorized tender wherever on the planet, it nonetheless qualifies as “adequate cash.” Which means two folks can select to settle in Bitcoin after worth has modified palms. That is why Nigerians go after the second-best possibility: funding.

“The funding behaviour we’re seeing completely suggests these ought to be handled as securities,” Koroye stated. “Nigeria doesn’t function beneath the Howey Take a look at framework, which suggests our securities classification depends on SEC specialists with their cumulative years of examine and expertise.”

In keeping with Koroye, an omnibus regulation that treats all cryptocurrencies as securities, till confirmed in any other case, is the most secure first step right into a market that has exploited tons of of 1000’s of Nigerians. 

Some business stakeholders notice that Bitcoin is totally different from different cryptocurrencies. Bitcoin is the one digital asset not issued by any firm or entity. In contrast to cryptocurrencies which had been issued by firms akin to Chainlink Labs ($Hyperlink) or different blockchain-tied tokens used for lending, Bitcoin solely exists via the efforts of miners; it’s programmed to have solely a finite quantity in circulation. 

“Bitcoin is a little bit of an outlier,” stated Ayotunde Alabi, CEO of Luno Nigeria, the UK-headquartered crypto firm working in 4 African nations. “It wasn’t launched via an ICO [Initial Coin Offering], it has no central promoter, and folks don’t depend on the efforts of a single entity to affect its worth. Globally, that’s why many regulators deal with it extra like a commodity.”

If Nigeria sticks with this blanket strategy, it might come at a value. Startups constructing round Bitcoin might battle to fulfill licencing and compliance calls for designed for conventional monetary establishments. Innovation may gradual, and smaller gamers could also be pushed out altogether.

It additionally creates confusion round taxes. Securities and commodities are taxed in another way. Securities typically entice capital positive aspects taxes, and the reporting necessities are extra complicated. Common merchants and companies accepting Bitcoin funds could be uncertain whether or not they’re answerable for capital positive aspects, value-added tax (VAT), or revenue tax, particularly when the asset’s worth adjustments rapidly. Customers could under-report or overpay, which is dangerous for financial participation and tax assortment.

Treating Bitcoin as a safety could provide short-term management, however it might introduce long-term uncertainty, each for the market and the regulators making an attempt to manipulate it.

“In Nigeria’s case, the present framework is constructed to deal with digital belongings as securities, which supplies the SEC oversight and the chance to introduce guardrails because the market matures,” stated Alabi. “Whereas Bitcoin could not neatly match the securities definition, it is sensible that the regulatory strategy right here begins broad. Over time, we might even see extra nuanced classifications emerge because the ecosystem evolves.”

The case for commodities

Commodities are belongings which have intrinsic or extrinsic worth. Examples like gold, grains, and oil cross this straightforward litmus check. Gold can be utilized to make wonderful ornaments and precise cash, and crude oil is processed to offer vitality fuels. Grains (maize, rice, or sorghum) have intrinsic worth due to their consumption worth.

Good types of commodity cash have a secure and identified worth, and are straightforward to maintain in an alternate account. These underlying elements make these commodities fascinating, creating demand for them.

Bitcoins, resulting from their volatility, are usually not good models of account and don’t qualify as clear, conventional commodities. The argument for its shortage will not be a powerful sufficient case both, as one thing might be scarce however nonetheless not be beneficial or secure if there isn’t actual, constant demand for it. Nevertheless, the speculative funding alternative in Bitcoin helps it to retain demand. 

Whereas Bitcoin doesn’t have intrinsic worth like bodily commodities, it has a singular digital intrinsic attribute that’s thought of beneficial. The digital asset is essentially the most recognised instrument of worth that may be transmitted throughout the web while not having permission from particular intermediaries.

Extrinsically, Bitcoin is pushed by worth mobility—sarcastically, one of many the explanation why it isn’t a transparent commodity—demand, utility, and societal belief, which drives community results. Per River, a Bitcoin monetary companies firm, 4% of the world’s inhabitants—about 320 million folks—holds Bitcoin. As extra folks purchase, commerce, or maintain Bitcoin, it turns into simpler for brand new customers to take part. The presence of this huge person base gives better liquidity and extra potential transaction companions.

But, a commodity classification has its tradeoffs. In conventional commodity markets, like gold or oil, regulators have clearer oversight over each futures and spot markets. Bitcoin is generally traded on spot markets, that are the common markets the place folks purchase and promote the precise asset. These markets are usually not totally regulated in lots of nations, together with Nigeria. That makes it tough to trace worth manipulation or shield on a regular basis customers from unfair practices.

Even in nations just like the US, the place Bitcoin exchange-traded funds (ETFs) are allowed and function beneath strict guidelines, these ETFs nonetheless get their costs from the worldwide Bitcoin spot market. If the spot market is unstable or influenced by offshore exercise, that instability can move straight into regulated funding merchandise.

“Nigeria has an enormous peer-to-peer market,” stated Olayimika Oyebanji, a lawyer and head of progress at Arcus BTC, an institutional Bitcoin lending platform. “So there’s an enormous query across the SEC’s [ability] to control that market.” Oyebanji pointed to the EU’s Markets in Crypto-Property (MiCA) framework as a extra structured strategy—one which categorises crypto belongings into three teams: digital cash tokens (EMTs), asset-referenced tokens (ARTs), and “different tokens.” 

Bitcoin falls into the final group, Oyebanji defined, as a result of it doesn’t match as an EMT or ART. 

“MiCA doesn’t regulate Bitcoin straight; it regulates what folks do with it, via service suppliers,” he stated. “That’s what you count on from a complete framework. It’s actually going to make sense if Bitcoin is classed as a commodity, not a safety.”

But, this setup signifies that whereas a “commodity” label may cut back regulatory stress and encourage innovation, it doesn’t take away the dangers. A weakly supervised market—particularly one so depending on international worth alerts—can nonetheless expose customers to fraud, volatility, and misinformation.

Is a hybrid mannequin the longer term?

A 3rd college of thought proposes a center floor, one which adjusts regulation primarily based on how Bitcoin is definitely used.

Oluwasegun Kosemani, convener of the Naija Bitcoin Convention and chief bitcoin officer of Bitcoin retail startup Botmecash, argues that Bitcoin ought to fall beneath a hybrid regulatory strategy—neither totally consultant cash nor strictly property, however a mix of each.

“Bitcoin ought to be handled uniquely,” he stated. “It may be a retailer of worth like a commodity, but in addition utilized in transactions like cash. So regulation should mirror each ends, relying on what use case is being served.”

This use-based strategy is gaining traction in nations like Switzerland and Japan. In Switzerland, the authorized classification of a cryptocurrency relies on its use. If it’s used for funds, it’s handled in another way than if it’s used as an funding or utility.

Within the European Union, the MiCA regulation takes an identical strategy. It doesn’t deal with all crypto belongings the identical. As an alternative, it creates separate guidelines—some primarily based on monetary laws, others extra like commodity laws—relying on the character of the asset and the way it features. Japan additionally has a framework that adjusts regulatory remedy in accordance with function, displaying that hybrid approaches are shifting from concept into observe.

Bitcoin is an element cash, half commodity, and half speculative cash. Shoehorning the digital asset into one definition might be limiting; regulation ought to comply with how the use circumstances evolve, fairly than a blanket strategy.

Mark your calendars! Moonshot by TechCabal is again in Lagos on October 15–16! Be part of Africa’s high founders, creatives & tech leaders for two days of keynotes, mixers & future-forward concepts. Early chicken tickets now 20% off—don’t snooze! moonshot.techcabal.com